KnowBe4 Compliance Training for HIPAA, PCI DSS, and SOC 2: What It Covers and How Alternatives Compare (2026)
Read summarized version with

Key takeaways
- KnowBe4 compliance training combines compliance-related modules in SAT Foundation and SAT Advanced with Compliance Plus, an optional add-on that KnowBe4 says includes 1,000+ items. Compliance Plus covers regulations such as HIPAA, PCI DSS, and GDPR, plus business ethics, harassment, and employment law.
- Among the frameworks and rules reviewed in this article, only PCI DSS and NYDFS Part 500 set an annual training cycle. HIPAA, ISO/IEC 27001, SOC 2, the NIST Cybersecurity Framework, NIST SP 800-53, and the FTC Safeguards Rule leave the schedule to the organization.
- Auditors and regulators ask for proof of training, such as dated completion records, policy acknowledgments, and documentation kept for as long as the applicable rule requires, which is six years under HIPAA.
- Completion records prove that training happened but cannot show that risk fell: NIST says learning-program measurement "must go beyond simply achieving compliance," and a 2024 meta-analysis of 69 studies found that training changed measured behavior far less than knowledge and attitudes, with a behavior effect that was not statistically significant.
- Adaptive Security is a security awareness training and phishing simulation platform that creates deepfake video and audio, voice, SMS, and email simulations built from public OSINT and each employee’s role, with optional custom executive deepfake personas. For compliance teams, it adds pre-built HIPAA, PCI DSS, SOC 2, ISO 27001, and NYDFS modules, plus auditor-formatted exports by framework, employee, and date range.
In September 2026, the HHS Office for Civil Rights announced a $700,000 HIPAA settlement with Ambry Genetics after a phishing attack on an employee’s email account, and the corrective action plan requires Ambry to train all workforce members on its Security Rule policies. KnowBe4 compliance training delivers HIPAA and PCI DSS content through two layers: compliance-related modules in the SAT Foundation and Advanced libraries, and the KnowBe4 Compliance Plus add-on.
KnowBe4 Compliance Plus is an add-on compliance training library that covers regulations such as HIPAA, PCI DSS, and GDPR, plus business ethics, harassment, and employment law. A training library supplies the content, but auditors and regulators also expect proof that the training reached the right people at the right time.
HIPAA and PCI DSS also require training on the organization’s own policies, plus proof that training happened: HIPAA requires documentation that training was provided, and PCI DSS requires annual policy acknowledgments. Policy training, dated records, and acknowledgments all depend on how the organization configures a platform’s campaigns, policy tracking, and reports.

What Does KnowBe4 Compliance Training Include in 2026?
As of November 2026, KnowBe4 compliance training has two layers: compliance-related modules inside the SAT Foundation and SAT Advanced training libraries, and the Compliance Plus add-on, which KnowBe4 offers at any subscription level. KnowBe4’s pricing page describes SAT Foundation as a library of 200+ pieces of content and SAT Advanced as the Foundation library plus additional KnowBe4 Studios premium content.
Compliance Plus carries the regulatory and workplace compliance topics, while the two SAT libraries hold a smaller set of regulation-titled modules. In KnowBe4’s public catalog, those SAT modules include PCI DSS and GLBA content in both plans, with HIPAA and ISO 27001 items added in SAT Advanced.
What Is KnowBe4 Compliance Plus?
KnowBe4 Compliance Plus is an add-on compliance training library for organizations that already hold a KnowBe4 Security Awareness Training (KSAT) subscription. KnowBe4 lists it in the ModStore, the vendor’s training content catalog. As of November 2026, KnowBe4’s pricing page states that the library includes “1000+ pieces of fresh content.”
KnowBe4’s Compliance Training Library page sorts Compliance Plus content into eight topic areas, and only one is regulatory data protection. The eight areas fall into three groups:
- Data protection regulation: The Data Privacy and Data Protection area covers regulations such as HIPAA, GDPR, South Africa’s Protection of Personal Information Act (POPIA), and PCI DSS, according to KnowBe4.
- Workplace and HR compliance: Five areas cover Business Ethics; Diversity, Equity and Inclusion; Employment Law; Harassment and Discrimination; and Workplace Safety.
- Professional and corporate topics: Two areas cover Professional Development and Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) topics.
According to the Compliance Plus product page, organizations can incorporate their own policies and procedures into brandable modules. They can also upload training and video content that complies with the Sharable Content Object Reference Model (SCORM) to the KnowBe4 learning management system. Compliance Plus campaigns run automatically and include reporting. Newsletters, documents, and posters come with the library as learning aids.
KnowBe4’s “Why Consider Compliance Plus” guide (2025) lists multiple content publishers and “35+ core languages” for the library. The same guide states that compliance training can be tailored by role or team.
KnowBe4 Training Modules by Regulation and Subscription
The table below compares KnowBe4’s regulation-titled training content by subscription, based on searches of KnowBe4’s public ModStore catalog on November 2, 2026. SAT Advanced includes the full SAT Foundation library, so its column lists only the items it adds.
| Regulation | SAT Foundation | SAT Advanced adds | Compliance Plus add-on |
|---|---|---|---|
| HIPAA | No HIPAA-titled module | HIPAA Overview for End Users (15-minute module); The What, Why, and How of HIPAA (4-minute video); The HIPAA Rundown (document) | 13 HIPAA-titled items, including HIPAA Compliance Refresher (12 min), HIPAA: Business Associates (25 min), HIPAA: Covered Entities (30 min), HIPAA: Hybrid Entities (30 min), and HIPAA for Healthcare Staff (20 min) |
| PCI DSS | Payment Card Industry (PCI) Simplified (30 min); Basics of Credit Card Security (18 min) | Business Conduct Series: PCI DSS - Retail Stores (8 min) and PCI DSS - Corporate Offices (10 min) | PCI DSS 4.0.1: Getting To Know the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (10 min); Perspectives with Quiz: PCI - Handling Credit Card Information (6 min); four PCI videos of about 2 minutes each |
| GLBA | GLBA: Information Security Awareness Training (15 min) | No additional GLBA-titled module | Four mobile-first modules: GLBA: Introduction (5 min), GLBA: The Pretexting Rule (4 min), GLBA: The Safeguards Rule (5 min), and GLBA: The Financial Privacy Rule (4 min) |
| ISO 27001 | No ISO 27001-titled item | ISO 27001: The Requirements (document) | Protecting Valuable Data - ISO 27001 (7 min) |
| SOC 2 | No SOC 2-titled item | No SOC 2-titled item | No SOC 2-titled item |
For HIPAA, the role-specific modules for business associates, covered entities, and hybrid entities sit only in the Compliance Plus add-on, while PCI DSS basics appear in both SAT plans. None of the three content tiers listed a SOC 2-titled item, so SOC 2 programs on KnowBe4 draw on its general security awareness content.
How KnowBe4 Compliance Campaigns, Policies, and Certificates Work
Based on KnowBe4’s knowledge base as of November 2026, the compliance training workflow runs in five steps:
- Find the content: Administrators locate Compliance Plus items in the ModStore, where each one shows an orange compliance badge next to its title.
- Create the campaign: A compliance training campaign can use a relative duration, such as three weeks from each user’s enrollment, and can enroll users automatically when they are added to a target group after launch. KnowBe4 recommends “running a compliance training campaign once every quarter.”
- Attach policies: The Policy Management feature can store, distribute, and track an organization’s policy acknowledgments. Administrators add each policy as a PDF or URL and can assign it in the same campaign as the training content.
- Monitor progress: Administrators download a spreadsheet of each user’s progress. If they hold SAT Advanced, they can also give compliance experts a security role that lets them manage and monitor compliance campaigns.
- Export evidence: Administrators generate reports as CSV or PDF files, depending on the report type, and learners can download or print their own completion certificates.
KnowBe4 HIPAA Training and PCI DSS: Does KnowBe4 Cover the Requirements?
KnowBe4 covers the content side of HIPAA and PCI DSS training requirements: as of November 2026, its SAT libraries and Compliance Plus add-on include HIPAA and PCI DSS modules. Both requirements also call for training on the organization’s own policies and for training records, and PCI DSS adds annual policy acknowledgments.
KnowBe4 provides campaign, policy, and reporting features that can produce dated records and acknowledgments. Each organization still has to configure those features, supply its own policy content, and retain the records for as long as the applicable rule requires.
KnowBe4 HIPAA Training Against the HIPAA Security and Privacy Rules
The table compares each HIPAA training requirement with what KnowBe4 HIPAA training provides and what the covered entity or business associate must add. Requirements come from the eCFR text of 45 CFR 164.308(a)(5) and 45 CFR 164.530(b) (current as of November 2026), and KnowBe4 details come from its public materials as of November 2026.
| HIPAA requirement | What KnowBe4 provides | What the organization must add |
|---|---|---|
| Security awareness and training program for all workforce members, including management (164.308(a)(5)(i)) | HIPAA modules in SAT Advanced and Compliance Plus; campaigns with automatic enrollment and relative due dates | Assign training to every workforce member, including managers, and document the program |
| Four addressable specifications: security reminders, protection from malicious software, log-in monitoring, and password management (164.308(a)(5)(ii)) | Security awareness content and simulated phishing campaigns, which the HHS Office for Civil Rights (OCR) October 2024 cybersecurity newsletter calls "an excellent method of providing security reminders" | Assess each specification, then implement it, or document why it is not reasonable and appropriate and implement an equivalent alternative if that is reasonable and appropriate (164.306(d)(3)) |
| Training on the covered entity’s own policies and procedures for protected health information (PHI), as appropriate to each member’s functions (164.530(b)(1)) | Brandable modules that can incorporate the organization’s own policies; SCORM upload; Policy Management for policies added as a PDF or URL | Write and maintain the policy content and assign it by role |
| New workforce members trained within a reasonable period; affected members retrained after a material policy change (164.530(b)(2)(i)) | Automatic enrollment of users added to a group, with due dates relative to each user’s enrollment | Define the onboarding window and trigger retraining when policies change |
| Documentation that training was provided, kept for six years (164.530(b)(2)(ii) and (j)(2); 164.316(b)) | Reports exported as CSV or PDF; learner-downloadable completion certificates | Retain the records for six years from creation or the date last in effect, whichever is later |
HIPAA places retention on the covered entity or business associate, which must keep training documentation for six years whichever platform it uses. Under 45 CFR 164.316(b), Security Rule documentation must also be available to the people responsible for the procedures and reviewed periodically. The Privacy Rule’s training standard is written for covered entities, while the Security Rule’s training standard applies to covered entities and business associates.
KnowBe4 PCI Training Against PCI DSS Requirement 12.6
The table compares each training sub-requirement of PCI DSS v4.0.1 (June 2024) Requirement 12.6 with what KnowBe4 PCI training provides and what the organization must add. KnowBe4 details reflect its public materials as of November 2026.
| PCI DSS requirement | What KnowBe4 provides | What the organization must add |
|---|---|---|
| 12.6.1: formal security awareness program that makes all personnel aware of the security policy and their role in protecting cardholder data | PCI modules in SAT Foundation, SAT Advanced, and Compliance Plus | Define the program and include the entity’s own information security policy and procedures |
| 12.6.2: program reviewed at least once every 12 months and updated as needed to address new threats and vulnerabilities | 60+ built-in reports on training and phishing results that can inform the review | Run and document the annual program review |
| 12.6.3: training upon hire and at least once every 12 months, through multiple methods of communication, with an annual policy acknowledgment | Automatic enrollment; relative due dates; Policy Management acknowledgments tracked in each campaign | Schedule hire and annual training, collect annual acknowledgments, and keep the program records and acknowledgments that assessors examine |
| 12.6.3.1: training on threats and vulnerabilities that could impact the security of cardholder data and/or sensitive authentication data, including phishing and related attacks and social engineering | Phishing and social engineering training content and simulated phishing | Confirm the content covers both topics, since assessors examine the training content |
| 12.6.3.2: training on acceptable use of end-user technologies | Policy Management can distribute the entity’s acceptable use policy with training | Write the acceptable use policy and train personnel on it |
Training content does not satisfy Requirement 5.4.1, a separate technical requirement to detect and protect personnel against phishing attacks, and anti-phishing tools do not satisfy Requirement 12.6.3.1. In PCI DSS v4.0.1, the applicability notes for Requirements 12.6.3.1 and 5.4.1 each say the two are separate and distinct requirements and that meeting one does not meet the other, so a compliant program needs both.
Which Compliance Frameworks Require Security Awareness Training?
Security awareness training compliance requirements appear in HIPAA, PCI DSS, and ISO/IEC 27001. SOC 2 examines training under its Trust Services Criteria, and the NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 lists it as a voluntary outcome. HIPAA requires a security awareness and training program for all workforce members, and PCI DSS requires a formal security awareness program that makes all personnel aware of their role in protecting cardholder data.
ISO/IEC 27001 requires competence and awareness for certification, and SOC 2 criterion CC2.2 focuses on communicating security information through a security awareness training program. Financial institutions under the FTC’s jurisdiction must also comply with the FTC Safeguards Rule, and firms licensed, chartered, or registered under New York’s Banking, Insurance, or Financial Services Law must comply with the New York State Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) cybersecurity regulation, 23 NYCRR Part 500.
The Framework-to-Training Requirement Map
The Framework-to-Training Requirement Map compares five frameworks by what each primary source requires, how often it requires training, what evidence an auditor or regulator expects, and how long records must be kept. HIPAA takes two rows because its Security Rule and Privacy Rule set separate training duties.
| Framework | Training requirement | Primary source | Frequency the source sets | Evidence expected | Record retention |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HIPAA Security Rule | Security awareness and training program for all workforce members, including management; four addressable specifications: security reminders, malicious software protection, log-in monitoring, and password management | 45 CFR 164.308(a)(5), HHS | None fixed; "periodic security updates" | Documentation of the program and required activities | 6 years (164.316) |
| HIPAA Privacy Rule | Training for all workforce members on the covered entity’s own protected health information (PHI) policies and procedures | 45 CFR 164.530(b), HHS | New members within a reasonable period; affected members after a material policy change | Documentation that training was provided | 6 years |
| PCI DSS v4.0.1 | Formal program (12.6.1); annual program review (12.6.2); training with policy acknowledgment (12.6.3); phishing and social engineering content (12.6.3.1); acceptable use (12.6.3.2) | Requirement 12.6, PCI SSC | Upon hire and at least once every 12 months | Program records, training content, and personnel acknowledgments | None specified |
| ISO/IEC 27001:2022 | Competence (Clause 7.2), awareness (Clause 7.3), and Annex A control 6.3 on awareness, education, and training | ISO (standard text sold by ISO) | None; the organization decides | Records of competence; Advisera’s audit guidance adds defined competencies per role and staff awareness | None specified |
| SOC 2 (2017 Trust Services Criteria) | CC1.4: training to maintain competence; CC2.2: security awareness training program (point of focus) | AICPA | None | The auditor tests the organization’s own controls; a Type 2 report covers operating effectiveness over a period | None specified for training records |
| NIST CSF 2.0 | PR.AT-01: awareness and training for personnel to perform general tasks; PR.AT-02: awareness and training for individuals in specialized roles | NIST CSWP 29 | None; voluntary outcomes | Not prescribed | None specified |
Among these five frameworks, only PCI DSS sets a fixed training cycle: upon hire and at least once every 12 months. HIPAA sets a new-hire window of “a reasonable period” and a six-year documentation rule. ISO/IEC 27001, SOC 2, and the NIST CSF leave frequency to the organization’s own policy, which ISO and SOC 2 auditors then test.
HIPAA Security Awareness Training Requirements Under 45 CFR 164.308(a)(5)
HIPAA security awareness training is mandatory: 45 CFR 164.308(a)(5) requires every covered entity and business associate to “implement a security awareness and training program for all members of its workforce (including management).” The standard lists four implementation specifications, all labeled addressable:
- Security reminders: “Periodic security updates,” which is the only timing language in the training standard.
- Protection from malicious software: Procedures for guarding against, detecting, and reporting malicious software.
- Log-in monitoring: Procedures for monitoring log-in attempts and reporting discrepancies.
- Password management: Procedures for creating, changing, and safeguarding passwords.
Addressable does not mean optional. Under 45 CFR 164.306(d), the entity assesses whether each specification is reasonable and appropriate, then implements it, or documents why it is not and implements an equivalent alternative if that is reasonable and appropriate.
The HIPAA Privacy Rule adds a second training duty for covered entities. Under 45 CFR 164.530(b), each covered entity must train all workforce members on its own policies and procedures for protected health information (PHI), as necessary and appropriate for their functions, with new members trained within a reasonable period after joining.
The October 2024 cybersecurity newsletter from the HHS Office for Civil Rights (OCR) adds that informing workforce members about new and emerging social engineering threats can be incorporated into the Security Rule training obligation.
PCI DSS v4.0.1 Requirement 12.6 Training Requirements
PCI DSS v4.0.1 Requirement 12.6 requires a security awareness program for all personnel, and PCI DSS describes security awareness education as “an ongoing activity.” Requirement 12.6 contains five training sub-requirements:
- 12.6.1, formal program: “A formal security awareness program is implemented to make all personnel aware of the entity’s information security policy and procedures, and their role in protecting the cardholder data,” as stated in PCI DSS v4.0.1.
- 12.6.2, annual program review: The program is reviewed at least once every 12 months and updated as needed to address new threats and vulnerabilities. PCI DSS v4 added this requirement, along with 12.6.3.1 and 12.6.3.2; all three were best practices until March 31, 2025, according to the PCI Security Standards Council (PCI SSC) summary of changes.
- 12.6.3, training and acknowledgment: Personnel receive training upon hire and at least once every 12 months through multiple methods of communication. They also acknowledge at least once every 12 months that they have read and understood the information security policy and procedures.
- 12.6.3.1, phishing and social engineering: Training covers threats and vulnerabilities that could impact the security of cardholder data and/or sensitive authentication data, including “Phishing and related attacks” and “Social engineering.”
- 12.6.3.2, acceptable use: Training covers acceptable use of end-user technologies.
PCI DSS v4.0.1 is a limited revision with “no additional or deleted requirements,” and the PCI SSC retired v4.0 on December 31, 2024. In its June 2026 request for comments, the council called v4.0.1 “the currently-published version of the standard” and sought feedback to help determine whether to revise it. As of November 2026, the council had not announced a successor version.
Requirement 5.4.1 sits outside Requirement 12.6. PCI DSS v4 added it as a technical “requirement to detect and protect personnel against phishing attacks,” so anti-phishing tools and awareness training answer two different requirements.
ISO 27001 Security Awareness Training Under Annex A 6.3
ISO 27001 security awareness training rests on three parts of ISO/IEC 27001:2022: Annex A control 6.3 (information security awareness, education and training), Clause 7.2 (competence), and Clause 7.3 (awareness). None of the three sets a training frequency.
Annex A control 6.3 requires organizations to explain to relevant people why security is needed and how to comply with security requirements. The organization decides which material to develop, for whom, how often to present it, and how to measure its effectiveness.
Clause 7.2 requires records as evidence of the competence of people working within the information security management system (ISMS). Clause 7.3 requires people to be aware of the information security policy, their contribution to the ISMS, and the implications of nonconformity. It does not require any written documents of its own.
Advisera, a company that publishes ISO 27001 documentation, tools, and training, lists three kinds of evidence that an auditor might look for under Annex A control 6.3, and missing evidence “is considered a nonconformity”:
- Defined competencies per job role: Documented expectations for the security knowledge each role needs.
- Proof of training: Records showing that people were trained against those competencies.
- Proof of awareness: Evidence that people know why security is needed.
ISO/IEC 27001:2022 is the third edition of the standard, published in October 2022 and amended once in 2024. The International Accreditation Forum’s transition rules ended the transition from the 2013 edition on October 31, 2025, and required 2013 certificates to expire or be withdrawn at that point.
SOC 2 Security Awareness Training Under CC1.4 and CC2.2
SOC 2 security awareness training is examined through two of the 2017 Trust Services Criteria from the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA), with points of focus revised in 2022. Under CC2.2, a point of focus describes improving personnel’s security knowledge and awareness “through a security awareness training program.” CC1.4 covers attracting, developing, and retaining competent individuals, with a point of focus on training to maintain technical competencies.
Points of focus illustrate a criterion without being mandatory checklist items. The AICPA states that using the criteria “does not require an assessment of whether each point of focus is addressed.”
In a 2023 post, the CPA firm Linford & Co. lists “Conduct annual security awareness training for all personnel” as an example control for CC2.2. Annual training is therefore one way to design a CC2.2 control, while the criteria themselves set no schedule.
The report type changes the evidence an auditor needs. The AICPA’s Journal of Accountancy (2016) explains that SOC 2, like SOC 1, comes as a Type 1 or Type 2 report. A Type 1 report addresses control design as of a specified date, while a Type 2 report adds an opinion on operating effectiveness “throughout a specified period.” Type 2 training records must therefore cover the whole period.
The AICPA proposed updated 2027 Trust Services Criteria in October 2026, open for comment through January 15, 2027. If approved, the new criteria would apply to “engagements beginning on or after Dec. 31, 2027.” Auditors’ CC2.2 expectations get a fuller treatment in Adaptive Security’s guide to SOC 2 security awareness training requirements.
NIST CSF 2.0 Awareness and Training (PR.AT)
The NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 (February 2024) places training under its Awareness and Training category (PR.AT), which has two outcomes. PR.AT-01 states that personnel are provided with awareness and training so they can perform general tasks with cybersecurity risks in mind, and PR.AT-02 states the same for individuals in specialized roles.
The CSF “may be adopted voluntarily and through governmental policies and mandates,” and it describes outcomes without setting a training frequency or a retention period. NIST’s control catalog, SP 800-53 Rev. 5 (Release 5.2.0, August 2025), is more prescriptive about training.
Control AT-2 requires literacy training for system users, including managers, senior executives, and contractors, as part of initial training and at an organization-defined frequency thereafter. Control AT-4 requires retaining individual training records for an organization-defined period.

How Do KnowBe4 Alternatives Handle Compliance Reporting and Audit Evidence?
KnowBe4 and its alternatives all have to support the same baseline documentation of security awareness training: dated completion records that show who completed which training and when, plus policy acknowledgments where PCI DSS applies. Platforms differ in framework-mapped exports, synchronization with HR information systems (HRIS) and governance, risk, and compliance (GRC) tools, export formats, and audit logs.
Those differences shape how much manual work an audit request creates. Teams comparing security compliance training alternatives to KnowBe4 should therefore judge each platform by how it produces the evidence frameworks require.
Compliance Reporting and Audit Evidence: KnowBe4 vs. Adaptive Security (2026)
The table compares KnowBe4 and Adaptive Security based on how each produces the evidence auditors and requestors ask for, using each vendor’s public materials as of November 2026. The baseline column shows what HIPAA, PCI DSS, ISO/IEC 27001, SOC 2, and the NIST CSF require of the organization, plus NIST guidance where noted, which any platform has to help produce.
| Evidence criterion | Framework baseline | KnowBe4 | Adaptive Security |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dated completion records | HIPAA: documentation that training was provided | Campaign progress spreadsheet; CSV or PDF reports; learner-downloadable completion certificates | Every completion, score, and timestamp logged automatically; exports by framework, employee, and date range |
| Policy acknowledgment | PCI DSS: annual acknowledgment of the security policy; HIPAA: training on the entity’s own policies | Policy Management tracks acknowledgments in each training campaign | "Policy distribution & attestation" listed on the pricing page |
| New-hire enrollment | HIPAA: within a reasonable period; PCI DSS: upon hire | Automatic enrollment of users added to groups; relative due dates; Active Directory or SCIM provisioning | HRIS sync; SCIM 2.0 provisioning; automated assignment, reminders, and manager escalation |
| Framework-mapped reporting | ISO/IEC 27001: records of competence | 60+ built-in reports; executive reports with a CISO template; no framework-specific report named in the KnowBe4 pages reviewed | Auditor-formatted exports by framework; Audit Preparedness board; published framework mapping |
| Audit trail | No training-platform requirement in these five frameworks (log rules such as PCI DSS Requirement 10 cover in-scope systems) | Audit Log of administrative actions, viewable for up to 180 days and downloadable as a CSV file | "Exportable audit logs" listed on the pricing page |
| Evidence sent to HR or GRC tools | No requirement in these five frameworks | Webhook API (SAT Advanced) for training and phishing data; Reporting API for custom reports and dashboards | Postback integrations to BambooHR, Vanta, and Drata; API and webhooks |
| Export formats | No requirement in these five frameworks | CSV or PDF, depending on the report | PDF, CSV, and JSON; Excel, PowerPoint, and image exports |
| Behavior evidence beyond completion | No requirement in these five frameworks; NIST SP 800-50 Rev. 1 guidance says measurement "must go beyond simply achieving compliance" | Phish-prone Percentage; SmartRisk Risk Score; "Reported" phishing view | Daily employee risk score weighted 50% on phishing simulation performance, 25% on training completion, and 25% on job risk |
Beyond the baseline column, Adaptive Security’s compliance, reporting, and integrations pages describe framework-labeled exports and prebuilt evidence postbacks to GRC tools. KnowBe4 documents policy acknowledgments, certificates, and API access to training data in one console.
KnowBe4’s Audit Log records administrative actions in the console, so its 180-day window covers that change history and is separate from training completion data. For the full list of evidence auditors request, Adaptive Security publishes a checklist for an enterprise security awareness training audit.
Framework-by-Framework Evidence: KnowBe4 vs. Adaptive Security
The table compares KnowBe4 and Adaptive Security framework by framework, by the training content each documents for that framework and the evidence each describes, as of November 2026. KnowBe4 content comes from its public ModStore catalog, and Adaptive Security details come from its compliance and healthcare pages and its Compliance & Certifications page.
| Framework | KnowBe4 | Adaptive Security |
|---|---|---|
| HIPAA | Content: Compliance Plus role modules for business associates, covered entities, hybrid entities, and healthcare staff, plus a refresher; one end-user module and one short video in SAT AdvancedEvidence: CSV or PDF completion reports, policy acknowledgments, and completion certificates | Content: Pre-built HIPAA modules covering covered entities, hybrid entities, and end-user obligations, assigned by roleEvidence: "Workforce training records, assigned HIPAA content, and simulation results" |
| PCI DSS v4.0.1 | Content: PCI modules in SAT Foundation, SAT Advanced, and Compliance Plus, including a Compliance Plus module on PCI DSS 4.0.1Evidence: The same reporting, policy, and certificate tools used for HIPAA | Content: PCI DSS modulesEvidence: "Onboarding and annual completion records, training content, and simulation reports" |
| ISO/IEC 27001:2022 | Content: One ISO 27001 module in Compliance Plus and one ISO 27001 requirements document in SAT AdvancedEvidence: The same reporting, policy, and certificate tools | Content: ISO 27001 modulesEvidence: "Role-based learning plans, completion records, and policy training history" |
| SOC 2 | Content: No SOC 2-titled item in the public catalogEvidence: The same reporting, policy, and certificate tools | Content: SOC 2 modulesEvidence: "Training assignments, completion records, and policy-specific learning content" |
| NIST CSF 2.0 | Content: No NIST CSF-titled item; NIST password-guideline videos appear in a "NIST" searchEvidence: The same reporting, policy, and certificate tools | Content: No NIST CSF module named; the mapping combines general awareness training, role-specific learning, and simulationsEvidence: "Learning progress, simulation outcomes, and human-risk reporting" |
KnowBe4 documents one set of evidence tools that applies to all of its training. Adaptive Security publishes a separate mapping for each framework and states: “These mappings describe support, not certification or a guarantee of compliance.” SOC 2, ISO/IEC 27001, and the NIST CSF do not require a course named after the framework, so general security awareness training can meet them when it produces the evidence auditors test.
Security Awareness Training Compliance Requirements by Industry
Security awareness training compliance requirements differ by industry. Healthcare organizations must comply with HIPAA, and retailers must comply with PCI DSS, plus the FTC Safeguards Rule if they issue their own credit cards to consumers.
Financial services firms follow the FTC Safeguards Rule if they fall under the FTC’s jurisdiction and no other financial regulator enforces the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA) for them. Firms licensed, chartered, or registered under New York’s Banking, Insurance, or Financial Services Law also follow the New York State Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) cybersecurity regulation, 23 NYCRR Part 500. PCI DSS applies to any financial services firm that handles payment card data.
Healthcare: How OCR Enforces HIPAA Training After Phishing Breaches
Enforcement by the HHS Office for Civil Rights (OCR) shows how OCR treats training after a phishing breach. When OCR announced its September 2026 settlement with Ambry Genetics, OCR Director Paula M. Stannard said: “Email phishing is a common cyberattack that can lead to a breach of PHI and reveal HIPAA Security Rule deficiencies.” A recent settlement illustrates the pattern:
- Ambry Genetics (2026): OCR settled with Ambry Genetics for $700,000 after a phishing attack on an employee’s email account, and the corrective action plan requires Ambry to train all workforce members on its Security Rule policies and procedures.
Ambry’s plan shows the content requirement: training every workforce member on the organization’s own Security Rule policies and procedures.
Verizon’s 2026 Data Breach Investigations Report (DBIR) healthcare snapshot, covering 1,438 confirmed breaches, found phishing as the initial access vector in 14% of breaches and a human element in 54%. The same snapshot reports that social engineering re-entered the top three breach patterns in healthcare.
Which Security Awareness Platform Is Best for Healthcare?
No single platform is best for every healthcare organization. Both KnowBe4 HIPAA training and Adaptive Security’s HIPAA modules support HIPAA security awareness training, and the better fit depends on six criteria drawn from HIPAA’s training duties and OCR enforcement:
- HIPAA role topics: Modules for covered entities and business associates, because the Security Rule applies to both and the Privacy Rule’s training duty applies to covered entities.
- Training on the organization’s own policies: The ability to load custom policy content, because the Privacy Rule requires training on the entity’s own PHI policies and procedures.
- Role-based assignment and new-hire timing: Assignment by job function and automatic enrollment, because the Privacy Rule requires training suited to each member’s functions within a reasonable period after joining.
- OCR-ready, dated reports: Records that show who completed which training and when, kept for the six years HIPAA requires.
- Simulated phishing as security reminders: Phishing simulations, which OCR calls “an excellent method of providing security reminders.”
- Languages per module: The language count of each required HIPAA module, because library-wide totals can hide modules offered in only one or two languages.
KnowBe4 HIPAA training is a better fit for organizations that already use KnowBe4 and want Compliance Plus role modules for business associates, covered entities, and hybrid entities, with policy acknowledgments in the same console.
Adaptive Security is a better fit for organizations that want pre-built HIPAA modules assigned by role and one-click compliance reports “for OCR audits, internal reviews, or board presentations,” according to its healthcare page. Its guide to phishing awareness training for healthcare employees adds that Adaptive reports click rate, time to report, and repeat behavior by clinical role.
Financial Services: FTC Safeguards Rule and NYDFS Part 500 Training
Two financial services rules covered in this article set security awareness training requirements, each with its own scope:
Experience the Adaptive platform
Take a free tour- FTC Safeguards Rule (16 CFR 314.4(e)): The rule applies to financial institutions under the FTC’s jurisdiction that are not subject to another regulator’s enforcement under section 505 of GLBA, such as mortgage lenders, short-term small-dollar lenders, finance companies, tax preparation firms, non-federally insured credit unions, and investment advisors that are not required to register with the SEC. Section 314.4(e) requires “security awareness training that is updated as necessary to reflect risks identified by the risk assessment” without setting a fixed frequency. The FTC’s business guidance advises firms to “schedule regular refreshers.”
- NYDFS Part 500 (23 NYCRR 500.14(a)(3)): The regulation applies to any person operating under a license, registration, charter, or similar authorization under New York’s Banking Law, Insurance Law, or Financial Services Law. Since April 29, 2024, it has required “periodic, but at a minimum annual, cybersecurity awareness training that includes social engineering for all personnel.” The limited exemption for small covered entities leaves this requirement in place.
Of these two rules, only NYDFS Part 500 sets an annual training cycle and requires social engineering content; the FTC Safeguards Rule does neither. Each covered entity also files an annual certification of material compliance, or an acknowledgment of noncompliance, by April 15 and keeps the records supporting it for five years.
NYDFS enforcement also reaches role-based training. NYDFS fined PayPal $2 million in January 2025 after finding that PayPal “failed to provide adequate training to address cybersecurity risks” and that the teams implementing a system change “were not trained on PayPal’s systems.”
Phishing remains a measurable entry point in the sector. Verizon’s 2026 DBIR Executive Summary found phishing as the initial access vector in 20% of the 1,300 confirmed breaches in its Financial and Insurance data, with a human element present in 65%.
KnowBe4 vs. Adaptive Security for Financial Services
Compared to regulation-titled content, KnowBe4 and Adaptive Security cover different financial rules. KnowBe4 lists GLBA modules and includes anti-money laundering among its Compliance Plus business ethics topics, while Adaptive Security lists NYDFS and anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism (AML/CFT) modules, as of November 2026.
In KnowBe4’s public catalog, both SAT Foundation and SAT Advanced include GLBA: Information Security Awareness Training (15 min), and Compliance Plus adds four mobile-first modules: GLBA: Introduction, The Pretexting Rule, The Safeguards Rule, and The Financial Privacy Rule. A search for “NYDFS” returned no results on November 2, 2026. KnowBe4’s banking product, the Customer Awareness Program, is built to train bank and credit union customers.
Adaptive Security’s compliance page lists pre-built modules for NYDFS and anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism (AML/CFT). For finance teams, Adaptive’s finance page describes reports on employee risk scores, training completion, and phishing failure rates by department, plus custom modules built from internal policies. That page names neither GLBA nor NYDFS, although Adaptive Security’s compliance page lists GLBA among its frameworks.
Financial institutions evaluating KnowBe4 alternatives should check modules titled for each rule that applies, NYDFS training that includes social engineering, and five-year retention for records that support an NYDFS certification. KnowBe4’s GLBA-titled modules are documented in its public catalog; for NYDFS training and department-level risk reporting, Adaptive Security’s public materials document more. Finance teams can find role-specific guidance in Adaptive Security’s guide to cybersecurity awareness training for finance employees.
Retail: PCI DSS Training for Store and Corporate Staff
Retail security awareness training centers on PCI DSS Requirement 12.6, which applies to all personnel who protect account data or can affect its security, including store staff and corporate office employees in those roles. Retailers that issue their own credit cards directly to consumers also count as financial institutions under the FTC Safeguards Rule definitions, so that rule’s training requirement applies to them too. Requirement 4.2.2’s separate technical rule for sending card numbers by email and other end-user messaging, and Requirement 5.4.1’s anti-phishing controls, are explained in Adaptive Security’s guide to PCI DSS email requirements.
PCI staff training, including KnowBe4 PCI training, is available from security awareness platforms that publish PCI DSS content. Four such options, as of November 2026, are:
- KnowBe4 SAT Foundation: Two PCI basics modules covering payment card industry rules and credit card security.
- KnowBe4 SAT Advanced: Separate PCI DSS modules for retail stores (8 minutes) and corporate offices (10 minutes).
- KnowBe4 Compliance Plus: A 10-minute module introducing PCI DSS 4.0.1, plus a 6-minute PCI card-handling module and short PCI videos.
- Adaptive Security: PCI DSS modules, with training mapped to Requirement 12.6 and evidence that Adaptive’s Compliance & Certifications page lists as “Onboarding and annual completion records, training content, and simulation reports.”
Verizon’s 2026 DBIR retail snapshot, covering 806 confirmed breaches, found phishing as the initial access vector in 9% of them and a human element in 58%. Verizon adds that retail cyberattackers, once focused mainly on payment card data, now target any data they can monetize. Verizon also advises giving people easy ways to report that they have become victims.

Beyond Checkbox Compliance: Why Completion Records Do Not Prove Reduced Risk
Completion records, which auditors and regulators collect, prove that training was delivered, but they cannot show whether employees behave more securely. NIST’s guide to building a cybersecurity and privacy learning program, SP 800-50 Rev. 1 (September 2024), states that measurement “must go beyond simply achieving compliance” and should also capture workforce capabilities, attitudes, and behavior changes.
Participants in NIST’s research also reported that their organizations “often used a limited number of metrics that did not provide a complete view of program effectiveness.” How completion records and behavior change fit together in a compliance program is the focus of Adaptive Security’s guide to security awareness training certification.
What Research Shows About Compliance-Driven Training
Independent research on security awareness training points to five findings that matter for compliance-driven programs:
- Knowledge improves more than behavior: A 2024 meta-analysis of 69 studies by Prümmer, van Steen, and van den Berg (Leiden University) found that training improved predictors of behavior such as knowledge and attitudes (d = 1.02, 95% confidence interval 0.58 to 1.46), but studies measuring actual behavior found a smaller effect that was not statistically significant (d = 0.36, 95% confidence interval -0.09 to 0.80).
- Mandatory training did not change clicks: In a study of 12,511 participating employees at a US fintech firm where training “was mandatory due to the organization’s regulatory environment,” Purdue researchers Rozema and Davis (2025) found that neither lecture-based nor interactive training had a significant effect on click rates or reporting rates.
- Embedded training can backfire: In a 15-month study of more than 14,000 employees, ETH Zurich researchers Lain, Kostiainen, and Capkun (IEEE S&P 2022) found that embedded training during simulated phishing exercises did not make employees more resilient and could make them more susceptible. The same study found that employee reporting allowed fast detection of new phishing campaigns.
- Programs measure completion most: NIST’s study of federal awareness programs, NISTIR 8420A (2022), found that training completion rates were the most common effectiveness measure (84%), while many participants emphasized that “success should be measured in ways beyond training completion rates.”
- Social engineering persists despite training: Verizon’s 2026 DBIR notes that social actions remain prevalent “despite ongoing efforts to reduce this risk through training and awareness,” and that pretexting calls for business-oriented rules and guidelines aligned with each target area, such as IT help desks.
The studies measure different programs, populations, and periods, so none settles the question alone. Taken together, they support pairing completion records with behavior measures, such as reporting rates and simulation results, when an organization judges whether compliance training reduces risk.
What Phishing Simulation Metrics Should Organizations Track?
Organizations should track phishing simulation metrics that show behavior: failure rate by lure difficulty, reporting rate, time to report, repeat failures, and the trend over time. NIST SP 800-50 Rev. 1 lists course completion separately from “Behavior Change per Participant,” which it measures, for example, by how many participants who received a phishing test email reported it appropriately. The five metrics below follow that distinction:
- Failure rate by lure difficulty: The share of recipients who click, enter data, or otherwise fail a simulation, grouped by how difficult the lure was. Purdue researchers (2025) found click rates of 7.0% for easy lures and 15.0% for hard lures, as rated on the NIST Phish Scale, so an unadjusted failure rate partly reflects which lures were sent.
- Reporting rate: The share of recipients who report the simulated phishing email, which is NIST’s own example of behavior change per participant.
- Time to report: How quickly employees report a simulated or real phishing email, which affects how fast a security team can respond to a live campaign.
- Repeat failures: Employees who fail more than once after follow-up training, which shows where coaching has not changed behavior.
- Trend over time: The same measures tracked across quarters, so results show whether behavior change holds across campaigns.
NIST also states that phishing exercises “should not be punitive, nor should any employee be called out for their response.” That guidance applies to every metric in the list, including repeat failures.
KnowBe4 measures phishing resilience with its Phish-prone Percentage, which it defines as “the percentage of employees that are prone to click on a phishing link,” calculated as total failures divided by emails delivered. KnowBe4 counts several actions as failures, including clicking links, opening attachments, enabling macros, replying, scanning QR codes, entering data on a landing page, and responding to callback phishing.
KnowBe4’s phishing reports can also show “Reported” results, which require the Phish Alert Button to be installed. Adaptive Security’s healthcare phishing guide, by comparison, says Adaptive reports click rate, time to report, and repeat behavior by clinical role.
What Behavior-Based Cybersecurity Metrics Should Organizations Track?
Behavior-based cybersecurity metrics measure what employees do in daily work as well as in simulations. NIST SP 800-50 Rev. 1 lists simulated attack response tracking, incident-reporting metrics, and longitudinal data on behavior change among its quantitative measures. Four behavior-based metrics build on that list:
- Real incident reporting: How often employees report genuine suspicious messages, calls, and events.
- Composite risk scores: Scores that combine simulation results, training completion, and role or access risk for each person and group.
- Security culture measures: Survey-based measures of attitudes, norms, and sense of responsibility, repeated over time.
- Longitudinal behavior change: Measure the same behaviors across quarters and years.
KnowBe4 provides two behavior-focused tools. Its SmartRisk Engine assigns Risk Scores to users, groups, and the organization on a 0-to-100 scale, though KnowBe4 says scores never fall below 10 or above 90, with risk factors grouped into security types such as Compliance Electives (compliance training completions) and Email Security (for example, reporting a phishing email with the Phish Alert Button). Its Security Culture Survey scores seven dimensions: Cognition, Behavior, Responsibility, Compliance, Attitudes, Communication, and Norms.
Adaptive Security’s risk scoring gives each employee a daily score from 1 to 100, weighted 50% on phishing simulation performance, 25% on training completion, and 25% on job risk. Adaptive can enroll an employee in targeted training when their score crosses a configured threshold. Adaptive Security’s complete guide to human risk scoring explains how such scores are built.
Is KnowBe4 Effective for Reducing Human Risk?
KnowBe4 provides the tools to measure whether its training reduces human risk, including the Phish-prone Percentage, the SmartRisk Risk Score, a “Reported” phishing view, and the Security Culture Survey. Whether a specific KnowBe4 deployment reduces risk shows up over time in those behavior metrics, since completion rates record only that training was delivered.
Independent research on training in general shows why behavior metrics matter more than knowledge or completion. A 2024 meta-analysis of 69 studies found that training improved knowledge and attitudes far more than behavior, and found no statistically significant effect on measured behavior.
A 2025 Purdue study of mandatory training at a US fintech firm also found no significant effect on click or reporting rates. Neither study names KnowBe4, so the findings describe security awareness training in general.
Adaptive Security vs. KnowBe4 Compliance Plus
Adaptive Security is a security awareness training and phishing simulation platform that creates deepfake video and audio, voice, SMS, and email simulations built from public OSINT and each employee’s role, with optional custom executive deepfake personas. For compliance teams that need audit evidence, Adaptive Security provides pre-built modules for frameworks including HIPAA, PCI DSS, SOC 2, ISO 27001, and NYDFS.
By comparison, KnowBe4 Compliance Plus is an add-on for KnowBe4 subscribers that covers security regulations and workplace compliance topics such as business ethics, harassment, and employment law, with content from multiple publishers. Adaptive Security’s compliance library centers on regulatory and security frameworks, including rules such as GDPR, CCPA/CPRA, and AML/CFT, and its pricing page also lists state and country harassment-prevention training.
What Compliance Features Does Adaptive Security Offer?
Adaptive Security exports reports formatted for auditors by framework, by employee, and by date range, according to its compliance page as of November 2026. It also logs every completion, score, and timestamp automatically. Its reporting library includes 40+ pre-built reports and three executive board templates: Audit Preparedness, CISO Review, and Leadership Update. The Audit Preparedness board provides “Audit-ready reporting on training, phishing, and policy compliance.”
Reports can be emailed automatically on a schedule, and postback integrations “push training completion and compliance evidence to BambooHR, Vanta and Drata.” Adaptive maps its training and simulation capabilities to eight frameworks, including SOC 2, ISO/IEC 27001:2022, the HIPAA Security Rule, PCI DSS v4.0.1, and NIST CSF 2.0. Its Compliance & Certifications page states that the mappings “describe support, not certification or a guarantee of compliance.”
Adaptive Security’s public pages list five further compliance capabilities:
- Framework modules: Pre-built training modules for HIPAA, GDPR, PCI DSS, CCPA/CPRA, SOC 2, ISO 27001, AML/CFT, NYDFS, and “dozens more frameworks,” with “50+ compliance modules” listed on the pricing page.
- Automated campaigns: Training assignment, reminders, completion tracking, escalation to managers for non-compliant employees, and completion certificates, handled automatically once a compliance calendar is set.
- HRIS and identity sync: Connections to HR information systems such as Workday, BambooHR, and Rippling, plus SCIM 2.0 user provisioning.
- SCORM export and AI-built modules: Export of any module as a SCORM package, and custom modules built with AI from an uploaded document or a framework name.
- Policies, audit logs, and languages: “Policy distribution & attestation,” “Exportable audit logs,” and Adaptive’s pricing page lists “40 languages with dubbed narration.”
Does Adaptive Security Provide Human Risk Analytics and CISO Reporting?
Yes. Adaptive Security provides human risk analytics through a daily employee risk score from 1 to 100, according to its risk page. The score weights phishing simulation performance at 50%, training completion at 25%, and job risk at 25%. Adaptive can enroll an employee in targeted training when their score crosses a configured threshold.
For CISO reporting, Adaptive’s reporting library includes a CISO review template alongside audit and leadership update boards, and reports export as PDF, CSV, or JSON. For finance teams, Adaptive reports risk scores, training completion, and phishing failure rates by department.
KnowBe4 offers its own versions of both. Its executive reports are built from widgets, with Security Admin, CISO, and Team Manager templates that print as PDF. Its SmartRisk Engine scores users, groups, and the organization on a 0-to-100 scale (KnowBe4 says scores stay between 10 and 90). KnowBe4 notes that console data “can take up to 24 hours” to appear in executive reports.
Which Is Better for SOC 2 and ISO 27001 Awareness Training?
For SOC 2 security awareness training, Adaptive Security’s public materials show more framework-specific support. Adaptive lists SOC 2 modules and maps its training to criteria CC1.4 and CC2.2 on its Compliance & Certifications page. KnowBe4’s public catalog showed no SOC 2-titled item on November 2, 2026.
For ISO 27001 security awareness training, both platforms offer titled content. KnowBe4 has an ISO 27001 module in Compliance Plus and a requirements document in SAT Advanced, and Adaptive lists ISO 27001 modules and maps its security awareness training to Annex A control 6.3.
Neither framework requires a course named after it. The SOC 2 training point of focus sets no frequency and is not assessed item by item. ISO/IEC 27001 leaves the content, audience, and frequency of training to the organization. Teams already running KnowBe4 security awareness training can therefore use its general content and reports to support either audit.
Which Platform Offers Better Phishing Simulations for Compliance?
The table compares KnowBe4 and Adaptive Security by the social engineering channels each documents for phishing simulations, as of November 2026. Those channels matter for compliance because PCI DSS Requirement 12.6.3.1 names phishing and social engineering as training topics and NYDFS Part 500 requires training that includes social engineering.
| Channel | KnowBe4 | Adaptive Security |
|---|---|---|
| Simulated phishing emails, with failure types ranging from link clicks and attachment opens to data entry on landing pages | Email, attachment, and QR code simulations | |
| Voice | Simulated Vishing and Callback Phishing (SAT Advanced) | Voice simulations |
| SMS | Not mentioned on the KnowBe4 pricing page | SMS simulations |
| Chat | No chat simulation listed (Microsoft Teams phishing is on KnowBe4’s H2 2026 roadmap); Microsoft Teams, Slack, and Google Chat integrations send training notifications and reminders | Coordinated attacks across email, voice, SMS, and chat |
| Physical tests | USB Drive Test; Physical QR Code (SAT Advanced) | Not listed on the Adaptive phishing simulations page |
For phishing and social engineering, both platforms simulate email and voice attacks. Adaptive Security fits organizations whose risk assessment flags SMS or chat lures, since its phishing simulations page lists both channels. KnowBe4 SAT Advanced fits organizations that also want physical tests, such as USB drives and QR codes. Both offer automated follow-up training, with KnowBe4 offering vishing simulations.
Alternatives to KnowBe4 Compliance Plus With Better Language Coverage
Library-wide language totals can hide per-module gaps, so buyers comparing KnowBe4 Compliance Plus alternatives for language coverage should check the language count of each required compliance module. KnowBe4 lists “35+ core languages” for Compliance Plus. Its language table marks Compliance Plus training as available in 35 of the 40 languages listed.
KnowBe4’s public catalog shows a language count on each module card. Buyers can check each required module’s language count there before purchase.
Adaptive Security’s pricing page lists “40 languages with dubbed narration.” Adaptive’s public pages do not give per-module language counts for its HIPAA content, so buyers should request them. A per-module language check covers four points:
- Required modules: A list of every compliance module the applicable frameworks call for, such as HIPAA role modules or PCI DSS Requirement 12.6 content.
- Language count per module: The count shown for each module, recorded separately from the library-wide figure.
- Narration and localization: Whether each language version is dubbed, subtitled, or text only.
- Workforce coverage: A comparison of each module’s languages with the languages spoken by the employees who must complete it.
Is Adaptive Security a Good Alternative to KnowBe4 Compliance Plus?
Adaptive Security is a good alternative to KnowBe4 Compliance Plus when a team wants framework-labeled security compliance content for HIPAA, PCI DSS, SOC 2, ISO 27001, and NYDFS. It also suits teams that want completion evidence pushed into governance, risk, and compliance (GRC) tools such as Vanta and Drata. Its simulations cover social engineering across email, voice, SMS, and chat.
KnowBe4 Compliance Plus is a better fit when an organization already holds a KnowBe4 security awareness training subscription and wants HR and ethics breadth, such as business ethics, employment law, and workplace safety. KnowBe4 sources that content from multiple publishers and tracks policy acknowledgments in the same console as training.
How to Choose Compliance Training Alternatives to KnowBe4
Organizations evaluating security compliance training alternatives to KnowBe4 should assess seven criteria, most of them tied to a framework requirement:
- Framework coverage: Modules for each regulation that applies, such as HIPAA role modules for healthcare or PCI DSS Requirement 12.6 content for organizations that handle payment cards.
- Own-policy training with attestation: Training on the organization’s own policies, which the HIPAA Privacy Rule requires, plus recorded acknowledgments, which PCI DSS Requirement 12.6.3 requires.
- Dated, exportable evidence: Completion records that show who completed which training and when, since HIPAA requires documentation that training was provided.
- Automated enrollment: Automatic enrollment of new hires from an HR information system (HRIS) or identity provider, because PCI DSS requires training upon hire and HIPAA requires it within a reasonable period after joining.
- Evidence retention: Retention that matches the longest applicable rule, such as six years for HIPAA documentation or five years for records supporting an NYDFS certification.
- Behavior metrics: Measures beyond completion, such as reporting rates and risk scores, because NIST says measurement “must go beyond simply achieving compliance.”
- Per-module languages: The language count of each required module, since library-wide totals can hide modules offered in only a few languages.
For compliance teams that need framework-mapped evidence, Adaptive Security provides auditor-formatted exports by framework, employee, and date range, and postback integrations that send completion evidence to BambooHR, Vanta, and Drata. For building an audit-ready program, Adaptive Security’s guide to enterprise cybersecurity awareness training requirements walks through the evidence package.
Frequently Asked Questions About KnowBe4 Compliance Training
How Often Is Security Awareness Training Required?
The required frequency depends on the rule. PCI DSS requires training upon hire and at least once every 12 months, plus an annual program review, and NYDFS Part 500 requires at least annual training. HIPAA sets no annual cycle, although HHS corrective action plans can require one: behavioral health provider Deer Oaks committed in 2025 to annual training for each workforce member with access to protected health information. SOC 2 and ISO 27001 leave frequency to the organization.
How Long Must Security Awareness Training Records Be Kept?
Retention depends on the rule. HIPAA requires keeping training documentation for six years from creation or the date last in effect, whichever is later, and NYDFS Part 500 requires keeping records that support the annual certification for five years. NIST SP 800-53 control AT-4 leaves the period to the organization, while PCI DSS, ISO 27001, and SOC 2 specify no retention period for training records. Recommended retention schedules appear in Adaptive Security’s guide to training data retention.
What Are the New HIPAA Requirements for 2026?
No new HIPAA training requirement is in force in 2026. HHS published a proposed Security Rule update on January 6, 2025, that would move training to a new section 164.308(a)(11). As of July 2026, HHS had moved the proposal to long-term actions with a July 2027 target, according to Davis Wright Tremaine, and HHS states that “the current Security Rule remains in effect.”
Who Must Complete Security Awareness Training Under HIPAA, PCI DSS, and NYDFS?
All three rules cover the whole workforce. HIPAA and NYDFS cover the whole workforce, and PCI DSS covers all personnel who protect account data or can affect its security. PCI DSS Requirement 12.6 covers all personnel, which PCI DSS defines as employees, temporary staff, contractors, and consultants with security responsibilities for account data or who can affect its security. For role-based scope, see Adaptive Security’s guide to end-user security awareness training requirements.
How Long Does KnowBe4 Compliance Training Take?
KnowBe4 training modules for HIPAA and PCI DSS range from a 4-minute video to 30-minute modules, based on KnowBe4’s public catalog in November 2026. HIPAA role modules in Compliance Plus run 15 to 30 minutes, and PCI DSS modules run 6 to 30 minutes. KnowBe4 recommends running a compliance training campaign once every quarter, and its guide uses a three-week relative duration for each user to finish.
Can Organizations Upload Their Own Compliance Training to KnowBe4?
Yes. KnowBe4 lets organizations upload SCORM-compliant training and video content to its learning management system and incorporate their own policies and procedures into brandable Compliance Plus modules. Its Policy Management feature also accepts policies as a PDF or URL, distributes them, and tracks acknowledgments. Policies can be assigned in the same campaign as training content.
Is a Phishing Simulation Required for Compliance?
None of the frameworks reviewed in this article names phishing simulations as a requirement. PCI DSS Requirement 12.6.3.1 requires training content on phishing and social engineering, and Requirement 5.4.1 requires technical anti-phishing controls. NYDFS Part 500 requires annual training that includes social engineering, and the HHS Office for Civil Rights calls simulated phishing emails “an excellent method of providing security reminders” under HIPAA. Simulations therefore support compliance evidence without being a named requirement.
Building Compliance Training That Produces Evidence and Reduces Risk
KnowBe4 compliance training covers HIPAA and PCI DSS content through its SAT libraries and the Compliance Plus add-on. Its campaigns, policies, and reports can produce audit evidence once an organization configures them. Compliance itself depends on training employees on the organization’s own policies and on keeping proof: dated records, policy acknowledgments, and retention that matches the longest applicable rule.
Showing that risk has fallen takes a further step: measuring behavior through reporting rates, simulation results, and risk scores alongside completion. To see how Adaptive Security assigns framework modules, automates campaigns, and exports audit-ready evidence, take the tour to stay audit-ready with Adaptive’s compliance capabilities.
As experts in cybersecurity insights and AI threat analysis, the Adaptive Security Team is sharing its expertise with organizations.
Get started with Adaptive Security



